Agenxy cultivates open technology

002

Three tests for an open standard

AbstractYou have a working design and a specification you paid to read. Before you can build the part and claim conformance, the same standard can put another price on permission.

You are a student with a working design. To check it against PCIe, you can join PCI-SIG or order the specification as a $4,500 printed copy for non-members.

That buys the text.

The permissions for making the part and using its name are separate matters. If you buy a finished part instead, ownership does not include the right to make another one, use the name or inspect the rules it follows.

Reading, making and declaring each need their own test

For Read, the published specification must be available free, without membership or a non-disclosure agreement.

Build requires implementation without membership payments or per-unit royalties, with the necessary patent licences available beyond the membership. Free reading does not settle the right to build.

Declare concerns a product that conforms: whether you may describe it as conforming, under the certification and logo conditions.

Agenxy grades a standard open when all three tests pass, partly open when reading is free but another test fails, and closed when the text costs money. Your permissions come from the terms. The parts on the shop shelf establish popularity.

Familiar parts come with restricted permissions

The terms behind the parts

StandardReadBuildDeclare
RISC-V instruction setFreeNo fee to use the ISACommercial use of the name licensed to members
OCP NIC 3.0, OAM accelerator moduleFreeRoyalty-free grant for compliant products, in the specification’s own licenceNothing in the licence or specification restricts a statement of conformance; OCP’s marks need its written consent, and the OCP Accepted mark is for paying members
SFF-TA-1002 card-edge connector (SNIA)Free, for internal usePatent licences on reasonable terms under SNIA’s policy; three makers have filed patent disclosuresNo logo or certification programme on SNIA’s SFF pages or in its process guide; SNIA’s policy reserves only its own marks, and suppliers state conformance themselves
USB Type-C and Power DeliveryFreeNo-fee, royalty-free patent terms for signers of the reciprocal Adopters AgreementLogo licence and certification cost; vendor ID US$6,000 or USB-IF membership at US$5,000 a year
ATXPower-supply guide free from Intel; the board outline survives only in archived copiesNo licence granted; the reader agrees to grant Intel a royalty-free licence to later patent claims on what the guide disclosesNo logo or certification programme; nothing found restricts stating conformance
PCIe, M.2Members, or a $4,500 hard copyPatent terms set among membersWords claiming compliance need PCI-SIG testing and an Integrators List entry, open to members; non-members need a licence agreement to use the marks or claim compliance.
DisplayPortMembersPatent pool at $0.20 per product, on top of member termsLogo requires membership
HDMIAdopters (1.3a free to evaluate)Annual fee plus per-unit royaltyAdopter Agreement

PCI-SIG’s specifications page excludes internal use and development for internal use from the restriction on commercially available AI systems. Using the text to create, train, enhance, develop, maintain or contribute to those commercial systems needs prior written consent, even after payment.

If you would prefer a free document, HDMI version 1.3a is available under a licence “solely to evaluate and discuss” the specification to determine whether to obtain an additional licence. Production requires the written Adopter Agreement.

USB supplies the free document and the reciprocal Adopters Agreement: no-fee, royalty-free patent terms for signers. Build passes. An independent vendor identifier is US$6,000, or is included in USB-IF membership at US$5,000 a year (USB-IF). Logo licensing and certification also carry costs. The free implementation rights therefore leave USB partly open at Declare.

PCI-SIG’s member programme requires testing and an Integrators List entry; non-members need a licence agreement to use the marks or claim compliance. Your part conforms. You still need permission to say so.

Agenxy’s survey grades 75 standards: 25 open, 39 partly open and 11 closed. Permissions remain restricted in 50 of the 75.

The same fee excludes people with less to spend

You can use a closed standard provided you can meet its terms. Before committing, allow for annual fees, agreements set among members and documents unavailable to the people relying on the finished product. A large manufacturer can put these in its budget. A student, researcher, small firm or owner checking their own computer has less to spend.

The fee is uniform. The burden is not.

Standards can stay useful without charging for access

Drafting specifications, maintaining tests and protecting certification marks all take work, and a buyer relying on a mark to identify products tested together has good reason to want it funded. Access need not pay for it.

OCP NIC 3.0 grants royalty-free rights for its content; OAM does so for compliant products. OCP’s marks require written consent, and OCP Accepted is for paying members. The charge attaches to optional recognition. The rules remain available to read and implement.

The RISC-V International FAQ states “There is no fee to use the RISC-V ISA.” (RISC-V International FAQ). Commercial use of the name requires a member’s licence.

Linaro’s 96Boards Consumer Edition Specification states: “The specification is completely open - that is anyone may build a board to the specification without payment of any fees or any licensing requirements.” (96Boards CE specification). Patent rights remain uncleared.

Access need not be sold, as it is under PCIe, DisplayPort and HDMI.

Your OCP NIC 3.0 card also uses SFF-TA-1002. Its patent policy provides for reasonable terms, without promising zero royalties. Agenxy assesses both standards: the product inherits both sets of obligations.

The card’s grant stops at the connector.

Missing interfaces limit what an open builder can make

Agenxy’s survey identifies 13 gaps. You can choose a different interface where one is available. Of nine high-speed connectors surveyed, none supplies a slim card edge with an explicit royalty-free grant. The OAM specification grants rights for compliant products using two 688-contact mezzanine connectors. Select that format if it fits your design; it does not supply the missing card edge.

For a display link, none surveyed passes all three tests. The free DVI 1.0 specification promised a royalty-free adopter’s agreement but grants no licence itself. Silicon Image later reported no-cost reciprocal licensing to adopters (SEC filing); the agreement’s terms were not located.

For an open card spanning 160 to 350 W, the survey found no option. OCP NIC 3.0 reaches 160 W; OAM accommodates more through a mezzanine module. USB Power Delivery reaches 240 W. Above that, open power specifications come from data-centre designs. OCP’s M-CRPS power-supply specification also describes home and office use, but is not final (OCP DC-MHS specifications).

For the host connection (PCIe and M.2: licence terms), no surveyed specification supplies an open replacement for PCIe. Until these gaps are filled, your open computer still needs some partly open or closed dependencies.

Essential computing must be accessible without permission

Patents and trademarks can coexist with open standards. Before investing, read each dependency’s terms. Restricted interfaces remain necessary for now.

Computing is as essential as education, medicine and information. Excluding people from it puts them at a disadvantage in a life that depends on it.

The student should be able to build the computer. No one should have to buy a corporation’s permission to take part in an essential of life.

Agenxy argues for essential interfaces that anyone can read, implement and accurately declare conformance to, so a reasonably functional computer can be built without corporate permission or payment. Standards bodies should publish their Read, Build and Declare answers on the front page, before a builder invests in the specification. A standard should specify the part, not select the maker.

Sources

Sources were consulted on 9 and 10 October 2026, with subsequent checks on 22 October 2026.